I don't think they should. In my opinion, it encourages users to upload. (Which can get abused though) If they remove it, there'd be a whole new flaming discussion to Bukkit: "BukkitDev, now this? What's up Bukkit?" Some users would be glad it's gone. Others would be crying about it. As almost everybody already flames BukkitDev, I find no reason to have another "debate that isn't needed.